CHAPTER 16—HIDDEN MEANINGS

NOTE: I have removed this chapter from my manuscript. I am editing it down to less than 450 pages (from 570), and have decided to stick with my family's story and unfortunately lose a lot of the less relevant parts, however interested I am in presenting history.

12 NOVEMBER 1852

Seeking respite from my troubled thoughts, I made my way to the garden among the fading autumn blooms, where I overheard haunting melodies carried on the breeze. Drawn towards the source, I sauntered to the slave quarters where the men who work in the cotton gin factory now live.

Among them was Ishmael, his voice soaring above the others in a soul-stirring spiritual. The song spoke to my soul, stirring up emotions that I couldn’t quite name.

Suddenly he noticed my presence, and the group fell silent, reminding me of the barriers between us. Was I being genuine in my desire to learn, or was I just trying to appease my guilt? Not wishing to intrude further, I nodded to Ishmael and walked back to the house, my mind torn between conflicting emotions.

Once in the parlor with my forgotten needlework in my lap, I gazed out the window and noticed Sally. An impulsive decision led me to call her inside.

“Sally,” I said as she entered, “do you know the song Ishmael was singing this morning?” I hummed part of it.

Her eyes widened, and she hesitated before answering. “Yes, Ma’am. It’s... it’s one of the old songs. From before.”

“Would you... could you tell me more about these songs? About the stories behind them?”

Her expression was a mixture of surprise and wariness. “I... I don’t know many of them, Ma’am. Sara-uniya—I mean, Black Judith—she knew more. But...”

The girl fell silent.

“What is it? What troubles you?”

“Ma’am,” she began hesitantly, “I could not help but overhear your conversation with Mr. LeBois last night.”

My heart quickened. Had she heard John’s reservations? Sally continued, her voice barely above a whisper.

“Thank you for your many kindnesses, Ma’am. But I do not want to cause any trouble between you and the master.”

Her words stabbed me like a thousand needles piercing my conscience with guilt. Anxiety gnawed at my insides as I remembered the slaves’ sharp ears and their keen ability to gather information about their own fates.

“Sally,” I said firmly, trying to ease her worry, “our discussions are our own. This is our house, and no one interferes with our decisions. Knowledge is a gift from God, and it should not be kept from those who seek it. If you wish to learn, I will teach you. But you must promise me. These songs and their meanings must stay between us and our family. Otherwise, it could put your life in danger.”

She nodded, her eyes wide with understanding. “Yes, Ma’am. I promise.”

As she turned to leave, I felt a sudden urge to reach out. “Sally,” I beckoned. She paused at the door, looking back at me with apprehension.

“Thank you for helping to understand better,” I said, my voice thick with emotion. “It means more than you know.”

A small smile flickered across Sally’s face before she ducked her head and hurried from the room. As her footsteps faded down the hall, I sank back into my chair, overwhelmed. 

As twilight descended, casting long shadows, I reached for my journal, compelled to capture this moment, these feelings, before they slipped away. My writing comes to me as a prayer:

Today, I glimpsed a world hidden beneath the surface of our own. A world of secret songs and stories, passed along in whispers and melodies. How much have we lost in our ignorance? How much beauty and wisdom lie dormant, waiting to be rediscovered? Oh Lord, guide me. Show me how to bridge this divide. Give me the courage to do what is right, even when it feels impossible. 

#

Soon after I penned my prayer, John joined me, a familiar concerned look on his face. Our conversations have become a source of tension, as we struggle to find common ground in our views. There used to be a time when we enjoyed lively discussions and laughter, but now it seems an unspoken tension lies between us.

“Louisa, what were you discussing with Sally?” 

John’s question was gentle, but held a hint of suspicion.

I lay down the Jane Austen novel I bought yesterday and had just started reading. My mind raced with how to explain without causing further disagreement. “She was telling me about the songs the slaves sing and their hidden meanings. It is fascinating.”

His expression grew serious. “Louisa, you know we have discussed this. You must be careful.”

It was hard to reconcile this man in his sixth decade with the one I met so many years ago. He used to speak out against injustice and praised my free spirit and unconventional thinking. But as he spoke, I couldn’t help but wonder how much he changed because of his own position of power and privilege.

My gaze followed his restless movements.

“I am not suggesting we throw open the gates and abandon all structure. I am simply saying that perhaps we need to reconsider how we treat those in our care,” I responded.

John’s expression softened. He came and sat beside me, lacing his fingers with mine. “Louisa, my love, you are so full of hope and compassion. It is one of the many things I adore about you. But we must approach this cautiously.”

I felt a twinge of disappointment at his words. This was not the passionate and idealistic man I fell in love with, but a cautious and hardened businessman who faces challenges never dreamed about before we arrived in this town.

“Perhaps you’re right, John. But does that mean we should give up on making any change, no matter how small?”

He let out an exasperated sigh. John stood up and gazed out the window, his back stiff and his hands clenched behind him. His eyes scanned the horizon, as if searching for an answer to the dilemma we faced.

“The pressure is unbearable,” he murmured. “Our competitors, the political landscape, our growing businesses... any sign of leniency could spell disaster for us all.”

I could not help but feel torn. I stepped towards him and placed a hesitant hand on his tense arm.

“But what if our stubbornness only fuels the flames of unrest?”

He sighed, running a hand through his graying hair. “You may have a point, dearest. But we must proceed with extreme caution.”

My heart skipped a beat at his words, torn between gratitude for his support and fear for what lay ahead. “Thank you, John.”

As he left the room, my mind raced with conflicting thoughts and emotions, each one pulling me in a different direction. As I took up my novel, I heard a soft melody drifting through the window, lulling me into a sense of comfort. I recognized Ishmael’s voice again, joined by others, the harmonies weaving together in the still night air.

But as I allowed myself to listen and contemplate their message, fear crept in. What if others could hear too?

Just broaching controversial subjects can bring down untold consequences upon us. Every conversation and interaction now feels like a potential risk. It is a constant battle between staying true to myself and keeping up appearances to avoid judgment and backlash from those around me.